Double Tall Key Lime Pie
This post may contain affiliate links. See site Terms here.

This Double Tall Key Lime Pie is not only thicker than most, but the filling is extra creamy and so simple to make. The secret is a little sour cream in the custard, which adds tang and creaminess. Also, it’s topped with tons of whipped cream – which is stabilized with a little gelatin so it doesn’t seep into the pie. Also, you have to use actual key lime juice – it adds so much brightness to the flavor and has a much more tropical taste than typical limes. This is THE key lime pie! It will be the best you’ve ever had.

For key lime juice, you can buy it at the store – this is my favorite brand Nellie & Joe’s – or you can squeeze them by hand – I have done this before and it tastes delicious but takes a while because key limes are small!
We really love key lime pie in our house and find that they are just not thick enough for us! Most key lime pies are pretty small and definitely don’t have enough whipped cream – this one is a double batch of the key lime custard filling with a double batch of whipped cream on top. And the graham cracker crust is thick and buttery – you’ll love the complement of the graham cracker flavor and crunch against the creamy and tart pie.


History of Key Lime Pie
The tasty sweet and tart pie is thought to have started in Key West, Florida, back in the late 1800s. Key limes are smaller and more aromatic than regular limes, and were cultivated in the Florida Keys and throughout the Caribbean. The reason for using sweetened condensed milk, which is a crucial ingredient, is probably that fresh milk and refrigeration were hard to come by in the isolated Florida Keys until the 1930s.
Sweetened condensed milk was created in1856, which turned out to be a game-changer for the Florida Keys. Fresh dairy was tough to find because of the area’s isolation, and the warm climate made food poisoning and other illnesses a concern due to the lack of refrigeration. As a result, canned condensed milk became vital to their daily lives.
Double Tall Key Lime Pie

Equipment
- springform pan
- microplane for zesting limes
Ingredients
Graham Cracker Crust
- 3 cups graham cracker crumbs
- 1/2 cup white sugar
- 1/8 teaspoon salt
- 3/4 cup butter, unsalted (melted)
Key Lime Filling
- 2 cans sweetened condensed milk (14 ounce can)
- 4 egg yolks
- 1 cup key lime juice (can use fresh squeezed key limes or from a bottle – I like this brand)
- 2 tablespoons lime zest
- 1/2 cup sour cream
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Stabilized Whipped Cream
- 2 cups heavy whipping cream
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 1/2 cup powdered sugar
- 2 teaspoons powdered unflavored gelatin
- 6 tablespoons cold water
Instructions
Graham Cracker Crust
- Preheat oven to 350°F.
- In a medium-sized bowl, mix the graham cracker crumbs, white sugar, and salt.
- Pour the butter into the mixture and mix until well incorporated. The mixture should be wet enough to press into the springform pan. You can add a tiny bit more of melted butter if it's not sticking together well.
- Press mixture into the bottom and sides of an 8 or 9-inch springform pan. It works well to use a measuring cup to press the crumbs up the side of the pan.It doesn't have to be perfect but try your best to to press the crumbs in fairly evenly around the pan.
- Place in pre-heated oven and bake for 8 minutes. Remove and set aside.
Key Lime Filling
- In a large bowl, add the sweetened condensed milk and egg yolks. Whisk until well incorporated and smooth.
- Then add the lime juice, lime zest, sour cream, and vanilla. Whisk until smooth.
- Pour filling into pre-baked pie crust. Bake for 18-20 minutes, until the custard slightly wobbles when you shake the pan.
- Remove from oven and let come to room temperature, then chill in the fridge for 4-6 hours (or the freezer for 2-3 hours).
Stabilized Whipped Cream
- Once the pie is cooled, you can make the best whipped cream for topping. (The best part about stabilized whipped cream is you can make and top the pie ahead of time! This whipped cream won't seep and will hold it's structure for up to a week in the fridge.)
- Begin by adding the 6 tablespoons of cold water to a small microwave safe bowl. Sprinkle the unflavored gelatin on top. Allow to sit for 3-4 minutes.
- Microwave for a few seconds (6-10) until the gelatin is fully dissolved. Stir the mixture then set aside to cool for a minute.
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, add the heavy whipping cream, powdered sugar, and vanilla extract.
- Whip the mixture on medium-high speed until the mixture starts to thicken.Once soft peaks form, turn the mixer to low speed.
- Slowly pour in the gelatin mixture and turn the speed back up to medium. Continue to mix until stiff peaks form.
- Once the pie has cooled, generously top with the whipped cream.If desired, add extra lime zest on top of the whipped cream for garnish.
- Slice into pie and enjoy! (Stores well for up to a week in the fridge, in an airtight container.)

I hope you get a chance to make this Double Tall Key Lime Pie – it’s the perfect crowd-pleasing dessert. Tag me @plumstreetcollective on Instagram if you decide to make this sandwich. Thanks for reading!